Soy protein isolate now costs about 41% less per gram of protein than the cheapest whey we track, pea isn’t far behind, and in trials both build the same muscle with a slightly bigger scoop.
Cost per kilo of actual protein, not powder, so a 65% vegan blend and a 90% isolate are compared fairly. Whey rows are live from our price scans. The other powders aren’t in our scans yet, so they are normal (non-sale) prices we checked on 17 Nov 2026.
For context, the typical (median) whey concentrate we track costs $107.33 per kg of protein, and the typical isolate $122.21.
Mostly, yes. When people eat the same total protein, trials find soy, pea and rice protein build the same muscle and strength as whey, and big reviews of the research find little or no difference in lean mass between plant and animal protein.
The real difference is leucine, the amino acid that switches on muscle building after a meal. Whey is about 11% leucine; most plant proteins are 7–8%. So to get the same effect as 25g of whey protein, you need a bigger serve. The table shows how much. Our leucine calculator explains the threshold.
The figure on the right of each card is how much of that protein matches the leucine in 25g of whey protein.
Even at the bigger serve, soy isolate works out at roughly $1.32 per whey-equivalent dose, against $1.65 for the cheapest whey concentrate.
$38.89/kg protein, cheapest we found
The best value right now. Soy isolate is about 90% protein, a complete protein, and the most neutral-tasting of the cheap plant options. At $38.89 per kg of protein (Bulk Nutrients, 1kg) it is around 41% cheaper than the cheapest whey concentrate. In a 2021 trial, vegans taking soy gained the same muscle as omnivores taking whey; they just needed more of it (about 58g a day against 41g).
Worried about hormones? See the FAQ below: the research on men is reassuring. The one real caution is allergy, as soy is a common allergen.
$43.37/kg protein, cheapest we found
Close behind soy at $43.37 per kg of protein. Pea isolate is 80% or more protein, rich in lysine but low in methionine, and in a 12-week trial it built the same arm muscle as whey. It is usually fine for people who avoid dairy and soy, though some find it causes gas. Plant powders tend to carry more lead than dairy, so pick a brand that publishes test results.
$43.05/kg protein, cheapest we found
Similar price to pea ($43.05 per kg of protein) and matched whey for strength and body composition in an 8-week trial. On its own it is low in lysine, so it works best mixed with pea, which is exactly what most vegan blends do.
$43.80/kg protein, cheapest we found
Pea and rice cover each other’s weak spots, so a blend is a complete protein in every shake. Plain blends are good value (Pure Product’s is $43.80 per kg of protein in the 5kg bag). Branded, flavoured vegan blends are a different story: many are only 64–70% protein and cost more per gram of protein than whey. Check the protein per 100g before you buy.
$61.20/kg protein, cheapest we found
Same dairy quality as whey, just slow-digesting, which is why people take it before bed. Long-term muscle gains are the same. Unflavoured micellar casein is currently about $61.20 per kg of protein, cheaper than most whey concentrate. It contains lactose and mixes thick.
$85.85/kg protein, cheapest we found
A high-quality, dairy-free animal protein. At about $85.85 per kg of protein it costs roughly the same as whey isolate, so it makes sense if you can’t have dairy, not to save money.
$100.55/kg protein, cheapest we found
Beef protein isolate is made mostly from collagen-rich parts, so it is naturally low in leucine; some brands add leucine back in. At $100.55 per kg of protein it is the most expensive option here. Collagen on its own is not a muscle-building protein at all: it has no tryptophan and very little leucine. Don’t count it toward your protein target for muscle.
Rough supermarket cost of 25g of protein. Indicative only: these are typical prices and protein values, not live data. For comparison, 25g of protein from soy isolate costs about $0.97 and from the cheapest whey concentrate about $1.65.
No, not at anything like normal intakes. A 2021 meta-analysis of 41 studies (Reed et al.) found soy protein and soy isoflavones had no effect on testosterone, free testosterone, estradiol or estrone in men, whatever the dose or duration, and an earlier meta-analysis (Hamilton-Reeves 2010) found the same for testosterone. Isoflavones are plant compounds that bind estrogen receptors weakly, hundreds to thousands of times less potently than the body’s own estradiol; they are not human estrogen. The published cases of breast growth in men involved extreme intakes, such as a man drinking about 2.8 litres of soy milk every day (Martinez & Lewi 2008). A scoop or two of soy isolate a day is nowhere near that.
When total daily protein is matched, yes for practical purposes. Trials found soy (Messina 2018 meta-analysis; Hevia-Larraín 2021), pea (Babault 2015) and brown rice (Joy 2013) produced the same muscle and strength gains as whey. Whey’s edge is that it has more leucine per gram, so it switches on muscle protein synthesis with a smaller dose. Use about 1.3–1.5 times the scoop of a plant protein (roughly 35–38g of protein instead of 25g) and the difference disappears.
Each has all nine essential amino acids, but pea is low in methionine and rice is low in lysine, so on its own neither scores as “high quality”. They cover each other’s gap, which is why pea and rice blends exist: a roughly 60/40 pea/rice mix scores in the high-quality range. You don’t have to combine them in the same shake if the rest of your day includes other protein, but a blend makes each shake complete.
On average, yes. US testing by Consumer Reports (2025) and the Clean Label Project (2025) found plant-based powders carried several times more lead than dairy-based ones, and chocolate flavours more than vanilla, because lead comes from the soil the crop and cocoa grow in. Those tests covered US brands, not the Australian ones on this page. For one scoop a day, the sensible response is to buy brands that publish third-party test results and to prefer unflavoured or vanilla, not to panic.
Branded vegan blends are often only 64–70% protein, because flavour, cocoa, gums and other add-ins take up the rest of the scoop, and they sell in smaller bags. Unflavoured soy, pea and rice isolates are 80–90% protein and sold by the kilo, which is why they come out far cheaper per gram of actual protein.
Casein is the same quality as whey but digests slowly, so it suits a shake before bed; long-term muscle gains are the same. Right now unflavoured micellar casein is around $61.20 per kg of protein, cheaper than most whey. Beef protein isolate is mostly collagen, so it is low in leucine unless the brand adds it, and at about $100.55 per kg of protein it is the most expensive option here. If you want an animal protein without dairy, egg white is cheaper and higher quality.
Unflavoured, a bit. Pea and rice are earthy and slightly gritty, and rice can be chalky; soy isolate is the most neutral of the cheap options. Mixing into a smoothie, oats or a flavoured shake hides most of it, and a little cocoa or a flavoured protein on top does the rest.
Prices for non-whey powders checked 17 Nov 2026. Several of these studies were funded by protein manufacturers; the conclusions above lean on the independent meta-analyses. General information, not medical advice.